Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Caffe Amici. We'd love to have your feedback!

Don't remember the name of your dish? Find it on our menu!

You are submitting your information to Caffe Amici and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. By submitting, you agree to the Popmenu , and .

Our Latest Reviews

Abranham126 15 days ago

Tiramisu

The tiramisu was absolutely delicious! Wonderful way to end the meal!

Benjamin 24 days ago

Rosa*

My favorite here. The creamy vodka sauce compliments the seafood in the best way. The mushrooms also add to the with the shrimp also give it some great texture.

Laura 25 days ago

Carbonara

By far the best I have ever eaten. I never share when I irder this.

Laura 25 days ago

Calamari Fritti

My husband cannot get enough of these. Fried to perfection. We always order extra dipping sauce!

Pat 30 days ago

Polpette (Meatballs)

#1 in town

Margaret Downing about 1 month ago

Marsala

A wonderful light entree. Bursting with flavor!

Stephanie about 1 month ago

Carbonara

Amazing!! This is the BEST carbonara I have ever had!

Marvin about 1 month ago

Bari*

This is one of my favs. Before the lockdown Cafè Amici was and still is a good place to dine. Friendly staff an owner. The menu is always good. Wide range of beverages, a few desserts which is always tasty.

Guest 3 months ago

Warm Salad

My girlfriend and I eat at the restaurant about once a month just for the warm salad. This has been a tradition for a decade.

Njenkins2018 3 months ago

Pescatore*

When we moved back from Europe years ago, we struggled to find an Italian restaurant that could measure up to what we'd become accustomed to. Thankfully a friend requested we try Caffé Amici. The food was spot on. We've been coming back religiously for over a decade now. We've taken countless guests with us and none have been disappointed.

Carmenoverton 3 months ago

Primavera

Always my favorite!

Heatherl175 4 months ago

Alfredo

I dream about this pasta!

Patty 4 months ago

Florentine Cheese Dip

This stuff is awesome! The triangles that come with it are also delicious!

Susanmarcus416 4 months ago

Dave's Special

This restaurant is the best kept Italian secret in Columbus! The food and the entire staff, Grattci, Julie, Gabe, James, Darma, Noel, Brittany, are awesome. We eat there just about every Friday night and the specials and regular dishes are over the top! We miss all of you and cannot wait to see you and enjoy a fabulous evening once again after this Corona Virus is over! Stay safe and love you all!!! Miss you, the martinis and zucchini fritte Gratt's! Love Dave's special!

Christiewlch 4 months ago

Ribeye Amici*

So delicious. first tome i tried it it just melted in my mouth. We are ordering it again tonight for pick up during this pandemic time. Please support our family owned businesses.

Al 4 months ago

Florentine Cheese Dip

This is a must have! The dippers that come with it are always so fresh too. This has such flavor and is even good left over reheated

Cheshirecat1951 4 months ago

Eggplant Parmigiana

I have tried many dishes at Caffe Amici and all are really good, but this one is the best of the best. The portion is huge and the taste is amazing.

Wmlahouse 6 months ago

Romano

Always a treat-chicken breast with a crispy breading top with a creamy spinach and tomato sauce. With a side of roasted vegetables it can't be beat. If your a fan of parmigiana, try Romano for a whole new level of flavor. You won't regret.

Alexisara12 6 months ago

Shrimp and Garlic

Best Italian food I have ever had. Straight to the point, the food was: -super flavorful yet very simple -felt very fresh -very balanced and creamy Would totally go back there anytime.

Cassandra 7 months ago

Carbonara

Spaghetti carbonara from Cafe Amici is our favorite pasta dish in Georgia!

Kcalderman9 15 days ago

Cannoli

We picked up Cannoli's for a special dessert to celebrate an anniversary and they were delicious! Love having a taste of Italy right here in Columbus!

Laura 25 days ago

Bolognese

I try and try to copy this recipie because its so delicious. I won't order speghetti from anywhere else in town.

Laura 25 days ago

Grilled Ribeye*

Timo be an Itlian joint they hae some of the best steak in town! Always grilled to perfection.

Laura 25 days ago

Gamberi All' Aglio

These are ridiculously decadent. I can't get enough of how good they are!

Christina about 1 month ago

Romano

This restaurant is by far my favorite place in Columbus. Hands down best food.

Margaret Downing about 1 month ago

Florentine Cheese Dip

A marvelous choice for an appetizer. It was plenty for two.

Kyle about 1 month ago

Eggplant Parmigiana

Absolutely the best eggplant parmigiana in town. Many people may see "eggplant" and be turned away by this dish but this is MUST try. The eggplant is breaded with perfection so that even after it is covered in the sauce it remains nice and crispy.

Stacy about 2 months ago

Eggplant Parmigiana

The BEST eggplant parmigiana that i have ever had. You actually can taste the eggplant! Thank you Cafe Amici's ❤️

Alyssa 3 months ago

Chicken and Broccoli

This is perfect for a picky eater like me. It is so delicious. It's hard to get anything else after having this as my favorite order.

Guest 3 months ago

Francese

My favorite dish at Cafe Amici!!!

Janettesworldview 3 months ago

Limoncello Cake

Iv never been to Sicily, but I know it's know for it rich lemon desserts and this was heaven ! It felt like I traveled around the world ! I highly recommend

Shannontho 4 months ago

Mushroom Ravioli

Love everything about this place. Food is amazing and the staff are family friendly. The best Italian restaurant in Columbus!

Tmtwwx3 4 months ago

Bari*

The Bari is delicious. The shrimp and pasta are always cooked perfectly in a white wine sauce. Very filling and great tasting.

Taylorbruhn 4 months ago

Shrimp and Garlic

Shrimp scampi was amazing!

Klwiesen 4 months ago

Baked Ziti

The baked ziti, and really everything I have had here is delicious. This is a delightful place with excellent foood.

Al 4 months ago

Primavera

This is always a go to for me! The vegetables are always cooked so well, and choosing the type of pasta and sauce is so wonderful. I always get the garlic! For someone not wanting meat this is a great dish!

Hellkamp 5 months ago

Caprese Salad

Fresh and light. This is my favorite dish. Even though it's an appetizer I could just get one of these and a salad and be set.

Andersonj107 6 months ago

Marsala

Excellent chicken Marsala - my favorite thing on the menu. Also the caesar salad is great too!

Megan 6 months ago

Alla Panna

My husband and I always get tortellini Alla Panna. I always ask for no mushrooms and they gladly put mine into my husband's dish. The Alla Panna at Cafe Amici is the closest we've found to the one we enjoyed at a small Italian restaurant that we loved while stationed in Germany. The waitstaff is the best in town! We have only had GREAT experiences at Cafe Amici! This is our go to place for Italian in Columbus and always bring our out of town visitors.

Andydana0602 8 months ago

Alla Panna

Great service and the food is excellent



PAST DRAWING WINNERS

July 2020:
Coming soon!

June 2020:
Elish, Crump's Landing
Homosassa, FL

May 2020:
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Amherst, NY

April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery 
Thousand Oaks, CA

March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD

February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA

January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC

December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL

November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA

October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR

September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA

August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA

July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY

June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA

May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY

April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA